Vintage Holiday Recipes From 1967


I recently came across an issue of McCall’s magazine from December of 1967, and while getting lost in all the great advertising, I stumbled upon some fun and tasty looking recipes from that magical year.  The Christmas season always brings along it’s own unique blend of tasty treats that are usually reserved for the holiday and not many other times of the year.  So chances are these recipes only saw print a few times through the years.  Well today, we’re pulling these old recipes out and sharing them with the world!

While all the food on this spread looks pretty tempting, the only recipe given is for the Cream Wafers that are pictured at bottom right.  They seem easy enough to make, and look pretty dang good too!  The main thing I’ve picked up on in these old recipes, and you’ll see as we go along, is they call for butter and not margarine.  These are my kind of people right here!

Now I know that aluminum foil isn’t food, but Reynolds Wrap got in on the game with some “recipes” of their own to try and move more of their product by giving you ideas of things to do with it.  You can wrap a child’s present with it, Christmas candles look more “gala” when they have some foil curled around them.  From the looks of things, I guess bunching a big glob of it up and sitting the candle in it as a base works too.  It even says you can line your fireplace with it to reflect it’s glowing warmth.

Now this one is certainly one of my favorites, as it features the always delicious snack, Bugles!  It also features Whistles and Daisy’s, but they are no longer on the market, so we just have to settle for what we can get.  As much as I love Bugles, I am more than a bit disappointed I missed out on ever trying the other two offerings.

I’m not so sure about the dip though.  Cream Cheese, Blue Cheese, and onions mixed with Cheddar and other stuff doesn’t sound too appealing to me.  Maybe it does you.


We’ll start at the top of the page here, and work our way down.  Now while I have been known to enjoy a slice of fried Spam or two in my time, I don’t believe I’ve ever worked up the courage to combine it with melted cheddar and a slice of cranberry sauce on toast.  Oh, and mustard.  There’s mustard on there somewhere.

The Hors d’Oeuvre balls made with Spam spread is most certainly out of the question for me.  That looks kind of disgusting actually.  Mixing it with onion soup mix and cream cheese before rolling it in paprika does not sound like a party to me.

Now at the bottom of the page…who doesn’t love a big old’ flaming ham?  Just like Mom used to make.  That Cure 81 brand ham is still in stores, and I can attest to its deliciousness.  The recipe for the Cheery Cherry Ham Glaze is a must though.  And heck, if you’re going that far, don’t forget to pick up some brandy so you can get that sucker on fire!

I know oranges played a bigger part in Christmases past, but to some folks, they are still a wonderful Christmas treat.  The recipes here for the punch and floating ice ring just might be a part of my spread this holiday season.

Who doesn’t love rice?  And ol’ Uncle Ben has been cooking it up for years and really knows what he’s doing.  The recipe at the top for Wild Rice Holiday Casserole looks pretty great actually.  The wild rice, cream of chicken, mushrooms, parsley, and shrimp would make a fine dinner, and not just for the holidays.

Wesson oil gets in on the act here with their recipe for fruit cake.  I know fruit cake is probably one of the most maligned foods on the planet, but I’ve found a simple mantra to be true when dealing with fruit cake.  When it’s good, it’s GOOD.  When it’s not, it’s not.  There’s not much of a middle ground with me and fruit cake.

My goodness, that recipe looks like it makes some rich fudge!  I wonder if it would be any good with Splenda instead of sugar.  Just kidding.  Give me the hard stuff.  Seriously though, I wonder if this makes a softer fudge or the classic hard fudge of years gone by.  I just might have to whip this up and see.

That just about does it, but I’ve got one more for you before I go….

It’s almost mind-boggling to think that the recipe clipping above is over 50 years old.  Well, it is for me anyway.  I know Rice Krispie Treats, or Marshmallow Treats as they’re called here, have been around my whole life, but I’m still amazed at just how long they’ve been around, and they’re still going strong.

Well that just about wraps it up for this look back at some of the finer holiday recipes from 1967. Pick one of these delightful treats and make it do your holiday party this year!